A Look at Response To Intervention in Rural School Districts
Lonnie Henry
EDLR 5313
Lamar University
3900 University Blvd.
Beaumont, TX 75799
Lhenry1@my.lamar.edu
Since 2004 Texas school districts, and teachers have been placed with the tremendous responsibility of implementing Response to Intervention (RTI). School districts in metropolitan areas are having an easier time; due, to the fact that they have bigger faculties, and in some cases more funding. That is not the case in many school districts in East Texas. In my school district, Ore City, we have a faculty shortage, and a budget shortfall, which puts the teachers and district in a tough situation when it comes to implementation. Due to the wording of the 2004 Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act, federal law allows for RTI in the local education agencies. Before RTI was implemented, the “Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children” was administered. The findings revealed many inconsistencies in eligibility determination. Students had a 25-50% chance of meeting the eligibility criteria (Burns, Griffiths, Parson, Tilly, and VanDerHeyden 2007).” With this in mind, it is important to properly diagnose the eligible students. This is why the government allowed the wording in the IDEIA Act to permit RTI.
RTI is the future of public schools. It is a multi-tiered learning delivery model that in theory diagnosis the student that is experiencing difficulty early in school. For some schools in the East Texas region RTI is a foreign word that has never been heard! At Ore City RTI is mentioned among the campuses, but at the high school it is more of something that is said in passing. The three tiers (primary, secondary, tertiary) target students out at level. The primary level focuses on the core curriculum, and the student’s ability to succeed at that level. If a student does not meet the normal criteria, he/she will then move into the secondary level where they will receive additional support services to help make them successful. If successful scores are still not reached, then the student will move to the tertiary level where they will receive even more support services. This will shape how schools function and survive over the coming decades. Most importantly, it will give every student the chance to succeed at a level that is conducive for that student without the student being labeled as a special education student.
The stumbling block to RTI is that it is a long process that will involve several teachers, and their varying opinions on RTI for each student. In theory, it looks like a good model to follow. The reality of it is that the student might actually suffer more from this process. The student will have a different teacher every year, and that teacher is going to have different beliefs toward RTI. If the student is not progressing at an appropriate rate, years could pass before diagnosing a learning disability. This could place the student years behind his/her appropriate level of education. Every student deserves to enjoy school, be educated, and be placed in his/her least restrictive environment. By following RTI, every student might not be afforded this opportunity.
This action research paper will answer three questions as they pertain to rural East Texas schools: What is the purpose for RTI? What is the best way to implement RTI, and what may be some of the problems associated with implementing RTI? These are three questions that are brought up when RTI is discussed among colleagues from this area. It is required by law that each school district comply with IDEIA. It is important for the schools all over Texas, especially the rural schools in our area get the information on RTI and apply it for the benefit of the students.
What is the Purpose for RTI?
Response to Intervention, or RTI, is appearing in our schools in response to the 2004 reauthorization of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act (IDEIA). With the heightened accountability ratings that schools face it is becoming increasingly more important. RTI can be defined as student centered assessment models that use problem-solving and research based methods to identify and address learning difficulties in children (Berkeley, Bender, Peaster, Saunders, 2009). RTI is designed to assist schools in pinpointing students who need additional assistance or more intensive instruction to achieve mastery. In most cases RTI is applied in the early years, and the students go undetected in the junior high and high school years. Behavioral intervention offered through RTI operates very similarly to the academic approach; meeting student needs to ensure success in the classroom. Academically there are two broad approaches to RTI, a standard approach, and a problem solving approach. The standard approach provides research based instruction to a group of students who are experiencing similar difficulties for a predetermined amount of time. The problem solving approach consists of a team of educators that define a student’s problem, plan intervention, implement intervention, and evaluate progress. Throughout the country today we see RTI interpreted somewhat differently because each state is responsible for setting its own regulations. Even though the interpretation differs, both models hold very similar approaches centered on student growth. The main components of both RTI models consist of a tiered approach which emphasizes; quality classroom instruction, universal screening, continuous progress monitoring, and researched based interventions. These concepts together establish a basis for effective instruction and help identify a student’s disability. Each tier establishes the level or degree of intensity in which instruction is set in order for the student to progress.
The Three Tiers
The Primary Tier, or Tier I, is introduced in the general classroom. This is the “universal tier”, or in other words all students receive this intervention. At least 90 minutes of daily uninterrupted instruction within the general education classroom is performed during this tier. The regular education teacher offers whole group instruction followed by universal screening. This screening, offered three times a year, will reveal if there was a misinterpretation during instruction by the class, or if the student is individually performing below expectation. The focus of RTI is on early intervention, the early provisions of services that build on the child’s strengths and address his or her learning needs (Coleman, Hughes, 2009). The teacher interprets this data over a period of time and establishes which students need more individualized instruction. This tier typically addresses the needs of approximately 80% of the students. (Gerzel-Short, Wilkins, 2009).
The Secondary Tier or Tier II consists of a more targeted instruction. It is at this level students receive a more intensive, research-based intervention. Support is often given during small group instruction within the regular classroom typically consisting of five students. This session usually provides 20 additional minutes of small group instruction in addition to the 90 minutes of whole group instruction offered during Tier I. Progress is closely monitored to ensure the intervention is effective. This intervention continues for a set amount of time, depending on the difficulty of the objective. The teacher will again interpret the data collected and determine if the student has successfully mastered the skill, or if more intense intervention is needed. This category usually includes at least 15% of students, normally considered at risk (Berkeley, Bender, Peaster, Saunders, 2009).
The Tertiary Tier, or Tier III focuses on an even more intensive or individual intervention. This intervention may be performed in the classroom, or a pull out program may be provided. Tier III usually consists of an additional 45-60 minutes of intense intervention. Individualized instruction focuses on specific goals determined from the lack of progress within Tier II intervention process. Progress is monitored more frequently or even constant. Special Education evaluation is considered after RTI intervention is exhausted and the student is still performing below grade level expectation. This researched based instruction is designed to target about 5 % of students in a given student body (Gerzel-Short, Wilkins, 2009).
In theory RTI should be a beneficial tool offering valuable information to teachers about student growth and level of achievement. RTI should address the needs of all students in order to provide early intervention in the classroom. The tiered approach offers support for students who before were in evidently left behind when instructional gaps or learning disabilities hindered growth.
What is the best way to implement RTI?
As mentioned earlier, the responsibility of each state to implement their interpretation of RTI has introduced more than one approach to the intervention process. Some states allow individual schools to choose from the problem solving or the standard approach, while others try to blend the two approaches into one module. Therefore there is no standard protocol for implementation. Through trial and error within other districts, social validity seems to be a key factor to accomplishing a smooth transition. Social validity is a way of describing whether a process leads to the desired result for a particular social group (Mahdavi, Beebe-Frankenberger, 2009). To ensure social validity, schools may also ask for partnership from the community when devising long term goals to ensure their approach is culturally appropriate. Acceptance by the facilitators is crucial during implementation. Administrators, teachers, paraprofessionals, parents and stakeholders within the community all have a need to know, understand and acknowledge the intervention and need for involvement. Implementation is more likely to be consistent when everyone feels like they are a part of a team working towards a common goal. Building this team requires, time, training, and commitment. Collaboration includes all parties working hand in hand with students, schedules, and interventions to ensure student achievement.
There are factors other than social validity to consider during implementation of RTI. Districts need to consider the funding, staffing, training, and data analysis. Not only do teachers need to work collaboratively, administrators have to fill leadership roles, and consider frameworks and schedules. The entire district has to be on board with the change, responsibility, and accountability RTI entails. Before RTI reaches schools, the state needs to identify the areas to be addressed, and the steps schools need to take. There are six steps or levels (FIxsen, Naoom, Blasé, Friedman, Wallace, 2005) that are useful for the state to consider during implementation. These steps have been proven effective in a non educational settings such a mental health and public administration. The National Center on Response to Intervention, State Implementation & Scaling-up of Evidence-based Practices (SISEP), the IDEA Partnership, and the Center on Instruction have agreed that the six-levels of implementation are useful when considering statewide implementation of RTI.
The first level to consider is exploration. This refers to considering change and ensuring a match between the needs of the state and what the program provides. This would be the time to consider the standard approach vs. the problem solving approach, study research, and ensure the program implemented will be beneficial. The next transition would be the installation phase. Within this level, preparation of what is to come needs to be addressed. Structural supports should to be set in place, and resources attained. This will aid in allowing the shift to occur without obstacles or persistence. The third level to take into account is the initial implementation. During this phase education, training, and organization occurs. The importance for knowing and understanding why the change is necessary to faculty and facilitators is crucial during this phase. Acceptance is key to the success of the implementation. The process of establishing social validity would occur and the community and stakeholders would be included during this level. Following initial implementation is full implementation. The program is in full swing, and becomes daily practice. The school, community, and stakeholders work together to manage the program. The fifth level or the innovation level entails the effectiveness of the implementation. It will be evident at this time that changes have to be made and the model may call for revision. During this phase it will be easy to see what worked and what didn’t, what will need to be changed and what was beneficial. The final level is the sustainability phase. This level will need to ensure the long-term survival of the implementation. The continuation efforts will need to consider the ongoing change in the future of education. Within this phase people, policies and practices will need to be flexible, but remain focused on the common goal and use of the RTI program.
Problems associated with RTI
Along with the implementation of any program, RTI has hit roadblocks within schools. Several complicating matters for school administrators include staffing, resources, training, and materials along with other requirements that are difficult for rural schools to find. The state of Texas has more children attending rural schools than any other state in the nation (Dykes). The East Texas area consists of several rural districts that depend on small business or one major corporation being the main source of income for the surrounding schools. These districts are faced with the overrepresentation of low socioeconomic students and the lack of resources attracting staff, and funding to fulfill the positions required for RTI implementation to be successful. Today’s economy is on a downward spiral, for the 2010-2011 school year many schools have cut positions, and made the decision to not replace staff who have left the district. Principals are faced with the responsibility implementing RTI with a skeleton staff. The district’s small size and remote location play a huge factor in implementation, scheduling, and community support. Teachers will face the challenge of dual roles, as RTI significantly impacts general and special education today.
For RTI implementation to be successful, the district as a whole has to be on board and ready for change. Many districts in Texas lack the support, and social validity necessary for implementation to be successful at this time. Within an elementary, RTI is more likely to undergo a smooth transition during implementation vs. a junior high or high school setting. Elementary’s consist of self contained classes with some pull out programs. This environment can be manipulated to sustain the three tiered model more so than the upper grades. The junior high and high school lack the cohesiveness necessary for RTI implementation to be effective. The two campuses will need to under go additional training and maybe even team building activities to work cooperatively. Teachers will be accountable for assessments and progress monitoring. Additional staff should be considered and schedules will need to be flexible, which seems impossible when jobs are being cut and teachers are moving to neighboring districts.
References
Ardoin, S.P., Connell, J.E., Koenig, J.L. & Witt, J.C. (2005). Application of a three-tiered response to intervention planning, decision making, and the identification of children in need of services. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 23, 362-380. doi:10.11771073428290502300405
Burns, M.K., Jimmerson, S.R., & Vanderheyden, A.M. (2007). Response to Intervention at School: The Science and Practice of Assessment and Intervention. Handbook of Response to Intervention (3-9). Behavioral Science: Springer US. doi:10.1007/978-0- 387-49053-3
Horner, R.H., & Sugai, G. (2009). Responsiveness-to-intervention and school-wide positive behavior supports-integration of multi-tiered system approaches. Exceptionality, 17 (4), 223-2327. doi:10.1080/09362830903235375
Jimmerson, S.R., & VanDerHeyden, A.M. (2005). Using response-to-intervention to enhance outcomes for children. California School Psychologist, 10, 21-32. Retrieved from Education Research Complete
Reynolds, C.R., & Shaywitz, S.E. (2009). Response to intervention: ready or not? or, from wait to fail to watch-them-fail. School Psychology Quarterly, 24 (2), 130-145. doi:10.1037/a016158

No comments:
Post a Comment